Rod Stewart – My Heart Can’t Tell Me No

This song was written for a country star, but Rod Stewart heard it first and decided to keep it for himself

My Heart Can’t Tell You No was never meant to be a Rod Stewart record. Simon Climie and Dennis Morgan wrote it with country star Barbara Mandrell in mind — a torch song for a singer who lived in exactly that lane. Stewart heard it, recognized what it could be in his own raspy voice, and claimed it. It became the biggest hit from an album full of them.

Keep watching: Rod Stewart – Baby Jane · Rod Stewart – Some Guys Have All the Luck

The writers knew their way around a hook. Climie and Morgan were the team behind “I Knew You Were Waiting (For Me),” the Aretha Franklin and George Michael duet that hit No. 1 the year before, and Morgan was a Nashville heavyweight with cuts for Ronnie Milsap, George Strait, and Mandrell herself. The song they handed over was built around a simple, painful idea: a man who knows he should walk away from a woman who belongs to someone else, and whose heart overrules his head every time he’s near her. It was a ballad about being helpless, and Stewart sang it like he meant it.

It arrived on Out of Order, released in May 1988 — Stewart’s fifteenth studio album, made with a formidable rhythm section: Bernard Edwards of Chic on bass, Andy Taylor of Duran Duran on guitar, Chic’s Tony Thompson on drums. The record threw off hit after hit, “Lost in You” and “Forever Young” among them, but this was the one that climbed highest.

The one he kept

Released as a single in September 1988, My Heart Can’t Tell You No reached No. 4 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No. 3 on the Adult Contemporary chart in 1989, the highest-charting single from the album and one of the defining soft-rock ballads of Stewart’s late-1980s run. He pointed to the acoustic guitar solo from his longtime collaborator Jim Cregan as the moment that made the record. The song had a long tail: more than two decades later, country singer Sara Evans took it back to the format it had been written for in the first place, cutting her own version in 2011 — closing a loop that started with a demo meant for Barbara Mandrell. But it’s Stewart’s reading, all ache and surrender, that most people mean when they name the song.