Carly Simon – That’s The Way I Always Heard It Should Be

A song sung from a woman’s point of view about the quiet despair of marriage — her parents’ bad one, her friends’ unhappy ones, her own cold feet — was written, in its words, by a man: Carly Simon’s close friend, a film critic who had never been married.

When Carly Simon’s first single arrived in the spring of 1971, her own record label was nervous about it. That’s the Way I’ve Always Heard It Should Be was not the kind of bright, simple song a label usually leads a debut with — it was a somber, searching meditation on marriage and disappointment, sung by a young woman weighing whether she wanted any part of it. Elektra’s staff worried it was too emotionally complex to introduce a new artist. They were wrong. The song reached the Top 10, earned a Grammy nomination, and helped make Carly Simon a star almost overnight.

Keep watching: Carly Simon – Top 5 Songs · explore more 70s →

The song’s most quietly surprising fact is in its credits. Although it’s delivered entirely from a woman’s perspective — taking in the narrator’s parents’ loveless marriage, her friends’ unhappy relationships, and her own ambivalence toward a partner eager to settle down — the lyrics were written by a man. Carly composed the music, and her close friend Jacob Brackman, a film critic for Esquire, wrote the words. The two had talked at length about their relationships, and Brackman channeled those conversations into a lyric that reads like a young woman’s private reckoning. Carly later reflected that, at the time, she thought it was unusual for couples to break up — and that, years on, nearly all her friends were divorced. The song’s clear-eyed unease turned out to be prophetic.

An art song that became a hit

Musically, it was unlike most of what was on the radio. The album Carly Simon was recorded at Jimi Hendrix’s Electric Lady Studios in New York and produced by Eddie Kramer, the engineer who had worked with Hendrix and Led Zeppelin. The song itself has been described as an art song, built on a semiclassical melody that critics have compared to the French composer Gabriel Fauré — a long way from standard pop songcraft. Released as a single in April 1971, it climbed to No.10 on the Billboard Hot 100 and No.6 on the Adult Contemporary chart, and topped local charts in cities from Boston to Rochester that summer. One music scholar would later call it an early soft rock masterpiece.

Its impact reached past the charts. At the 1972 Grammy Awards, That’s the Way I’ve Always Heard It Should Be earned Simon a nomination for Best Female Pop Vocal Performance — she lost to Carole King’s era-defining Tapestry — but Carly took home the Grammy for Best New Artist that night, an honor built in large part on the strength of this song. Within a single twelve-month stretch she released two hit albums, Carly Simon and Anticipation, announcing one of the most distinctive voices of the singer-songwriter era.

The performance that hid her terror

The footage most associated with the song captures a remarkable contradiction. In early July 1971, Simon performed at the Schaefer Music Festival in New York’s Central Park, and the performance was filmed for an ABC television special, Good Vibrations from Central Park, broadcast on August 19, 1971. On screen she is magnetic — barefoot in a slinky red dress, long-limbed and utterly commanding, projecting the ease of a natural star. The truth was the opposite: Simon suffered from paralyzing stage fright throughout her career, a terror of live performance that would shadow her for decades. What audiences saw as effortless poise was, in fact, courage. Carly Simon turns 83 in June 2026, and the song that her label feared was too much for listeners remains one of the defining debuts of its generation — proof that audiences were ready for honesty all along.