Billy Joel – Piano Man

He told the BBC audience the song was a true story, then explained why that needed saying: a lot of what he wrote was a pack of lies.

“This next song is a true story,” Joel told the room, and then explained why the clarification was necessary — because a good deal of what he wrote, he said, was a pack of lies. He was twenty-six, mustachioed, sitting at a piano in the BBC Television Theatre in London on May 16, 1975, playing the second of two songs for a program that gave its guests no staging, no dancers and no lighting rig to hide behind. The clip sat in the BBC’s archive for fifty years.

Keep watching: Billy Joel – It’s Still Rock and Roll to Me · explore more →

The Old Grey Whistle Test was built on that absence of spectacle. BBC2 put it out late at night from 1971 with Bob Harris speaking in a near-whisper between performances, and the format was the argument: if the song could not survive a plain camera and a studio floor, it was not much of a song. Joel played Travelin’ Prayer and Piano Man. That was the whole appearance.

He needed the exposure more than the booking suggests. In May 1975 he had three albums out and no American hit bigger than the one he was playing, which had stalled at No.25 the previous year. Streetlife Serenade had underperformed. Turnstiles was a year away, The Stranger two, and the run of records that made him a stadium act had not started. The man introducing a true story to a British television audience was a working musician who had been advised that Britain was worth the trip.

The true story was three years old by then. After a contract with his first label soured badly enough that he left New York over it, Joel took a job at the Executive Room, a piano bar on Wilshire Boulevard in Los Angeles, and worked there for about six months under the name Bill Martin. The waitress, the businessman, the real estate novelist and the old man nursing a gin and tonic were people who came in. Columbia released the song in November 1973 as the title track of his second album, and it climbed no higher than the mid-twenties, and it has outlasted every record that beat it that year.

Why a fifty-year-old tape surfaced in 2025

Producers combing the vaults for the HBO documentary Billy Joel: And So It Goes found material nobody had catalogued, and Joel decided to release it rather than let it go back in the box. The audio went out on July 26, 2025 as part of a hundred-track companion collection through Columbia and Legacy, credited as a 1975 BBC broadcast. The video premiered two days later. Joel has said more will follow, including the first performance anyone recorded of Scenes from an Italian Restaurant, from a show at C.W. Post, and his earliest television appearance, from 1972.

What makes this particular five minutes worth the archaeology is what the song had not yet become. In 1975 Piano Man was a narrative he had to introduce and explain, performed for people who mostly did not know it. By the end of the Madison Square Garden residency it was a ritual: twenty thousand people singing the chorus loudly enough that Joel could stop playing and let them finish it, which he frequently did. Both versions are the song. Only one of them is a story being told to strangers for the first time.

Joel cancelled his remaining concerts in May 2025, which means that for now every new Billy Joel performance reaching the public is one recorded decades ago and rediscovered. That is a strange way for a catalog to stay alive, and it is also the best possible argument for the sort of program the Whistle Test was. Somebody pointed a camera at a man and a piano, asked for nothing else, and the tape was still worth something fifty years later.